The standard advice on target setting is to make it ambitious enough to stretch the organization and achievable enough to stay credible, which is the kind of guidance that sounds wise and tells you nothing. Every target ever missed was set under that principle.
The variable that actually determines whether a number changes behaviour is not its size. It is whether a named person has to stand up and report against it, on a date, in front of people who will ask. Everything else is decoration. This assumes you know where your profit currently sits, which is what the profitability work establishes.
What makes a target believable?
Three things and no others: a specific number, a specific date, and a named person who reports progress against it on a fixed cadence. Remove any one and the target degrades into an aspiration, which is a thing organizations discuss rather than deliver.
The cadence is the element people underweight. A number reviewed annually is reviewed once, at which point it has either happened or not, and nobody has had an opportunity to correct course. A number reviewed quarterly generates four conversations, three of which can change the outcome.
Watch a related video: Contribution Margin vs P&L: The $4M Mistake.
What is wrong with the targets most businesses set?
They are precise about the ambition and vague about everything that would make it real. Compare the three versions below and note that only the third is something an organization can act on.
| Improve profitability” | “Reach 34% gross margin“ | “34% by Q4 2027, reported quarterly by the GM | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Has a number | No | Yes | Yes |
| Has a date | No | No | Yes |
| Has an owner | No | No | Yes |
| Can be missed | No | Not really | Yes |
| Changes behaviour | No | Briefly | Yes |
The row that matters is the fourth. A target that cannot be missed cannot be met either, because there is no moment at which anyone has to account for it.
A target that cannot be missed cannot be met. Without a date and an owner there is no moment at which anyone has to account for the number.
When should you publish it?
When you need the commitment effect more than you need the flexibility, which is most of the time in a business that has drifted. Publishing means stating the number to everyone who will be asked to deliver it, and for public companies it means stating it to the market.
Public manufacturers do this deliberately. A tools business reporting 30.7 percent adjusted gross margin against a stated long-range target of 35 to 37 percent has created an obligation to explain the gap every quarter until it closes. That obligation is the mechanism. It is available to a private company internally, at no cost, and almost nobody uses it.
When should you keep it internal?
When the number would be read by a customer or a competitor as information about your pricing intentions, and when you genuinely do not yet know whether the path exists. Both are real, and the second one is the honest reason most of the time.
If you have not built the profitability picture, you do not know whether four points are available, and publishing a number you cannot trace to specific accounts and products is a commitment to a guess. Do the arithmetic first, find the recoverable share, and publish a number built on it.
The other genuine reason to hold it internally is sequencing. A number published before the leadership team has agreed the sources it will come from produces a quarter of argument about whether the target is fair, rather than a quarter of work on the accounts and products that would deliver it. Agree the sources first, then publish, and the conversation on day one is about execution rather than about the number itself.
How do you pick the number?
Work backwards from what the business needs rather than forwards from what it currently earns. Sum your required spend on engineering, selling, service and capital as a percentage of revenue, add the return the business owes its owners, and that total is the margin you need rather than the one you would like.
Then test it against the recoverable share. At a thirty percent gross margin with two points of accumulated discount drift, roughly half of which is realistically recoverable, you have one point available from that source alone. Stack the sources, total them, and compare against the gap. If the sources do not reach the need, the target is not a target, it is a decision about whether this business is viable in its current shape.
Two points of drift with half realistically recoverable gives you one point. Stack the sources, total them, and compare against what the business actually needs.
About the Stagnation Assassin
Todd Hagopian is a Fortune 500 transformation executive who has generated $3B+ shareholder value across five turnarounds at Berkshire Hathaway, Illinois Tool Works, and Whirlpool. He is VP of Product Strategy and Marketing. Known as The Stagnation Assassin, he is the author of two published books: The Unfair Advantage: Weaponizing the Hypomanic Toolbox and Stagnation Assassin: The Anti-Consultant Manifesto. His blog is published in 15+ languages and read by operators worldwide. Bring him to your stage via his speaking page or connect with him on LinkedIn. His newest book is 10-Minute Transformation (February 23, 2027).
Speaking to a leadership team about to commit to a number? I run this backwards calculation live, against the audience’s own required spend, and the session ends with a number the room has agreed on rather than one the CFO announced. Details and booking are here.

