How to Prioritize Across a Portfolio

It is Sunday evening and you are looking at the week. Ten companies. Four board meetings this month, two of which are at businesses doing fine. One chief executive who calls you constantly, and another who has not called in six weeks. A diligence process on a bolt-on that will eat two days. And somewhere in that list is the one company where a week of your attention this month is worth more than everything else you will do this quarter combined.

I should say up front that I have run businesses inside acquiring companies and owned one myself rather than sitting in the operating partner’s chair with ten at once. What follows comes from the other side of that relationship, from watching which visits changed something and which ones produced a deck.

The hard part is not that you lack information. It is that nothing in the flow of the week tells you which company that is. This is the operating partner’s actual problem, and it is much less discussed than the value creation plans and the hundred-day playbooks it sits underneath. Those are covered in how to run year one after an acquisition. This is about how you decide where to be.

The default is to follow the noise

Left alone, attention goes to whoever asks for it: the loudest chief executive, the board meeting on the calendar, the deal in process, the company in visible trouble. Every one of those is a legitimate claim. None of them is a ranking, and together they produce a week that nobody chose.

It is worth being precise about why this is a hard problem rather than a discipline problem. The claims on your time are all legitimate. A board meeting is a real obligation. A chief executive asking for help is not being unreasonable. A live diligence process has a clock on it. Nothing in the week announces itself as the wrong use of you, which is exactly why the ranking has to be made somewhere other than inside the week.

What usually decides where the week goes

Three things, in my observation. Scheduled obligations, which were set months ago by availability rather than need. Escalation, which rewards the managers most willing to escalate. And familiarity, because everyone spends more time in the businesses they understand, which are rarely the ones where understanding is missing.

None of those correlate with value at stake. The company with the largest gap between what it is worth today and what it could be worth is often quiet, because quiet is what a business looks like when nobody has confronted it yet.

Watch a related video: CEO Focus: 40% of His Time on One Thing.

Watch on YouTube

How to Prioritize Across a Portfolio: The default is to follow the noise; Attention is the scarcest capital you control: Capital is allocated by an investment committee, on a cycle, with a process.; Three numbers should rank the list: Rank each company on value at stake, your marginal effect, and how long the window stays open.; Five situations, and only two of them need you: Most portfolio companies at any moment are in one of five situations, and the operating partner is the right resource for two of them.; Concentrate again inside the top fifth: Once the list is down to two or three companies, concentrate a second time inside the one at the top.; The companies you are not visiting: The companies you deprioritize still need to be governed, and the answer is rules rather than attention.How to Prioritize Across a Portfolio1The default is to follow the noise2Attention is the scarcest capital you controlCapital is allocated by an investment committee, on a cycle, witha process.3Three numbers should rank the listRank each company on value at stake, your marginal effect, and howlong the window stays open.4Five situations, and only two of them need youMost portfolio companies at any moment are in one of fivesituations, and the operating partner is the right resource fortwo of them.5Concentrate again inside the top fifthOnce the list is down to two or three companies, concentrate asecond time inside the one at the top.6The companies you are not visitingThe companies you deprioritize still need to be governed, and theanswer is rules rather than attention.
How to Prioritize Across a Portfolio: a visual summary of the main sections of this article.

Attention is the scarcest capital you control

Capital is allocated by an investment committee, on a cycle, with a process. The operating partner’s own time is allocated by a calendar, with no process at all, which makes it the least disciplined resource in a firm that prides itself on discipline.

It is also the resource with the widest variance in outcome. A dollar of capital does roughly what a dollar does. A week of an operator’s attention does nothing at all in a business that is running well, and it can change the direction of a business that is one unexamined assumption away from a much better answer. The whole argument for putting operators alongside capital rests on that asymmetry, and then the week gets filled by whoever called.

A dollar of capital does roughly what a dollar does. A week of an operator’s attention does nothing in a business that is running well, and changes the direction of one that is not.

There is a second asymmetry worth naming. Attention spent in the wrong company is not merely wasted, it is actively costly, because an operating partner in the room changes what the management team works on that month. A visit to a business that is running well redirects its leadership toward whatever you happened to ask about, which is rarely their highest priority and always your lowest-value question.

Three numbers should rank the list

Rank each company on value at stake, your marginal effect, and how long the window stays open. All three matter, and the second one is the one people skip, because it requires admitting that some problems are not yours to solve.

How much value is at stake here?

Not enterprise value. The gap between what the company is worth on its current path and what it would be worth if the thing you can see were fixed. A small company with a badly wrong price list can carry a larger gap than a big company running well, and the ranking should reflect that rather than revenue.

How much of the gap turns on something you can change?

This is the filter that thins the list fastest. A business waiting on a customer’s capital cycle, or on a permit, or on a new plant that is already being built, has a large gap and very little of it is responsive to you this quarter. A business whose order book has never been read properly is almost entirely responsive, and the work takes weeks rather than years.

Why the three have to be used together

Any one of them on its own produces a bad ranking. Value at stake alone sends you to the biggest company. Marginal effect alone sends you to the easiest problem. Window alone sends you to whatever is most urgent, which is where you were going anyway. Used together they usually produce a different answer from all three, and that difference is the point of doing it.

How long is the window open?

Windows close. The months after a close, when a management team expects change, are the cheapest time to make structural decisions. A pricing change is easier before the next contract cycle than after it. Capacity that has to exist before a selling season has a date attached. Two companies with identical gaps are not equally urgent if one of them has a door closing in ninety days.

Five situations, and only two of them need you

Most portfolio companies at any moment are in one of five situations, and the operating partner is the right resource for two of them. Sorting the list this way is faster than scoring it, and it makes the uncomfortable cases visible.

  1. Constraint-limited. Demand exists and the business physically cannot serve it, or cannot serve it fast enough. This one needs you, because the diagnosis usually contradicts what the management team believes and someone from outside has to be willing to say so.
  2. Price-limited. The business is busy and unprofitable, and the price list has not been rebuilt in years. This one needs you too, because it is the highest-return work available in most industrial businesses and almost nobody inside is empowered to do it.
  3. Demand-limited. Capacity is fine, pricing is fine, and the market is soft. Your attention will not create orders. Fund the commercial work, hold the cost line, and go somewhere else.
  4. Management-limited. The plan is right, the team cannot deliver it. This is a people decision, not an operating one, and the answer is in when to replace a portfolio company chief executive rather than in another site visit.
  5. Working. The thesis is on track and the leading measures are moving. Leave it alone. Adding attention to a business that is working is the most expensive habit in the job, because the cost is invisible and paid somewhere else.

Sorting ten companies this way usually leaves two or three in the first two categories. That is your list. The value of the exercise is not the ranking itself, it is that it gives you a defensible reason to not be somewhere, which is the part the calendar never provides.

Concentrate again inside the top fifth

Once the list is down to two or three companies, concentrate a second time inside the one at the top. Pareto recurses, and the same skew that separates companies also separates the problems inside any one of them.

This is 80/20 Squared, the recursion of the Pareto Principle inside its own top quintile: the top fifth of the top fifth, where a very small number of customer and product combinations hold a disproportionate share of the profit. It is normally run on a profit and loss statement, and it applies just as well to a portfolio and to a week.

In practice that means the deepest work goes into one company, not spread evenly across three. In a beverage filling equipment business, the finding that changed the whole thesis was that ninety percent of orders were the same three machines, customized at the end, in a business that described every machine as custom. Nobody found that by visiting more often. Somebody found it by reading the order book line by line, which takes days of one person’s attention and yields nothing at all if that attention is split across four businesses in the same week.

Depth in one company beats presence in three. The findings that change a thesis come from reading something line by line, which is not something you can do between flights.

The practical form of that is blocking a full week rather than three separate days. Reading an order book, walking a constraint on two shifts, or rebuilding a price list are not tasks that resume cleanly after an interruption. Three days spread across a month produce three arrivals and no findings.

The companies you are not visiting

The companies you deprioritize still need to be governed, and the answer is rules rather than attention. A small number of standing rules produces most of the protection that a visit would have provided, at almost no cost in time.

How do you stay informed without adding oversight?

Pick two or three leading measures per company and have them reported on the same rhythm, in the company’s own format, with no deck attached. You are not looking for detail. You are looking for the moment a trend changes, which is the signal that the company should move up the ranking.

Then set the rules that substitute for judgment you will not be present to supply. In the tank liner business I owned, the rules were unglamorous: no liner under a set minimum price whatever the calculator said, a flat fee for every penetration in the tank, a charged lip specification even when the customer wanted less, an expedite fee for the shorter lead time. Those rules stopped the business quietly subsidizing its worst work on days when nobody was watching the quoting.

The portfolio version is the same idea one level up. Standing rules about what requires a conversation, what gets decided locally, and what triggers an immediate call are worth more to a company you visit twice a year than an extra visit would be.

What happens when a company moves up the list?

Tell the chief executive it has, and say why. An operating partner who quietly reallocates attention toward a business creates the impression of scrutiny without the benefit of a shared diagnosis. Naming the reason converts the same visit from surveillance into work, and it tends to surface the thing you came to find several weeks earlier than you would have found it yourself.

What is the one exception to the ranking?

A business losing money at a rate that threatens its own existence outranks the arithmetic entirely. In a refrigeration business I worked on, the division was losing about $175 million a year and reached roughly $48 million of profit eighteen months later. Nothing else in a portfolio competes with a number like that, and no ranking exercise is needed to see it. What the ranking is for is the ordinary case, where four companies all look like they could use a visit.

The review that keeps the ranking honest

Redo the ranking monthly, in writing, and compare it to where your time actually went last month. The gap between the two is the real finding, and it is usually larger than anyone expects.

What does the comparison actually show?

Most operating partners who do this discover that a third or more of their month went to the company that escalated most, and that the company at the top of their own written ranking got a fraction of what they intended. That is not a discipline failure. It is what happens when one list exists on paper and the other one is a calendar that other people can write into.

The fix is mechanical. Book the time for the top-ranked company first, before the month fills, in blocks long enough to do the line-by-line work rather than in single days. Everything else fits around it, including the board meetings, which can usually be attended remotely more often than convention suggests.

Do the ranking once this week, on paper, for all ten. It takes about an hour, and the two companies that end up at the top are rarely the two you would have named from memory.

About the Stagnation Assassin

Todd Hagopian is a Fortune 500 transformation executive who has generated $3B+ shareholder value across five turnarounds at Berkshire Hathaway, Illinois Tool Works, and Whirlpool. He is VP of Product Strategy and Marketing. Known as The Stagnation Assassin, he is the author of two published books: The Unfair Advantage: Weaponizing the Hypomanic Toolbox and Stagnation Assassin: The Anti-Consultant Manifesto. His blog is published in 15+ languages and read by operators worldwide. Bring him to your stage via his speaking page or connect with him on LinkedIn. His newest book is 10-Minute Transformation (February 23, 2027).

Want the short version you can use this week? Pick your problem and get the matching free minibook.

Find my free minibook

The full diagnostic and 90-day playbook: 10-Minute Transformation, February 23, 2027.

Preorder 10-Minute Transformation

Not what you needed? Find Your Solution →